It’s all based on lies. There is no real gender dysphoria. This is a perverted manipulation of young people’s inherent insecurities during adolescence. There is bias here from the start in the answers and in the questions themselves. The use of contrived terms like “gender assigned at birth“ indicate that the person using them has already agreed to the premise of gender. What gender? There is sex, male and female. Gender is a modern word not very precise in its meaning and that’s exactly why this movement has latched onto it. Sex is a fact established by one’s biology unless we are talking about very rare anomalies (aka birth defects). There has been a whole new vocabulary developed to try label and describe what is basically mental fiction. In other words the whole so called problem of gender dysphoria is really all made up and symptomatic of an ailing society that is really suffering emotional and mental illness. It’s just so much fiction; they contort language to define what they think they mean and then mutilate the body to match the figment of their imagination. They are at war with themselves as God’s creation and so try to recreate who they are becoming gods unto themselves. It is perverted, suicidal and homicidal in nature. It is the ultimate expression of hatred toward God. It is simply sinful and therefore at its core a spiritual problem that has only one possible solution reconciliation with God by accepting his Son, Jesus Christ, as lord and savior.
A well constructed response pointing out the manipulation and even fabrication of language to support a narrative. I suspect ChatGPT is programmed with some degree of woke Narrative. ChatGPT may be direct programming like YouTube in manipulating what "gets through the gate" or seen with woke crafted algorithms. ChatGPT may be constricted intentionally or incidentally to woke based information on which to base its answers.
Christians may have it right, Jews may have it Right, and other God Fearing/Respecting Religions and Sects may have it right but the main form of your thoughts is : in all but very rare disorders "Sex is a fact established by one’s (God Given) biology ".
Unfortunately, the hate against Transgender people has already reached such a momentum that the affected can only be considered scapegoats for obvious reasons. As a person dealing with the issue, I have been writing about it for a long time. Without AI - but at the core emphasizing - and demanding that the main attention been given to mental health care. Gender Dysphoria - and that is not addressed - is most prevalent in people with Asperger’s. It is a form of autism and therefor requires affirming mental health care. The problems arise when a society cannot accept individuals “as is”, leading to the impression that there is “something wrong” with me. The entire issue will disappear when society does not exclude individuals that try to “fix” something that can best be treated with acceptance and love. The sad and quite sick part about this topic is the hate against autistic people for lack of understanding that autism is a disorder that has its roots in vaccinations and certain environ-mental settings. Think of aluminum poisoning. That the dark and sinister forces use the issue to divide the population is a fact. The Olympic games closing ceremony showed that with undeniable clarity. One can only wonder why there are so many religious people among the haters. The biblical advise exists however, that one should not so much care about the splinter in another one’s eye as one should focus on the log in one’s own eye. But if that would be the case, this would not be a “profoundly sick society”.
I suggest most of the Doctors and experts wanting to put an end to the industry that makes a lot of money with irreversible chemical and surgical "offerings" on minors come from a position of Love and Respect for Humanity. This group of people are likely to provide more time, love, care and long term counselling than those that approach a child's Gender Dysphoria with a heavy bias, if not one tracked mind, of a Gender Transformation as the most likely solution.
I think you touched on some really important issues including the link with Neurodivergent people and Gender Dysphoria. And then the link between big Pharma and the childhood 70+ vaccines schedule with not one of the vaccines being blind tested individually nor any combination profile safety testing. Vaccine adjuvants including Aluminum based ones are a real concern though there are also many other sinister elements in the way the vaccine industry operates and the contents they are using in the vaccines.
When a child is confused about their identity (which can include their Gender) they are very vulnerable and impressionable. Add to that the correlation of Gender Dysphoria and Neurodivergence and it becomes quite despicable for the industry that makes a lot of money with irreversible chemical and surgical "offerings" on minors to be pushing for quick paths (while they are minors) to this irreversible option.
When looking for religious guidance, I would look at the approach of the Jewish Scholars; in revising their texts and interpretations of what is morally right (over thousands of years) they look at a problem from as many angles as possible.
If you look up the "Unanimous Guilty Acquittal Rule"
"In Jewish law, a court’s decision is guided by the principle that “no one is to be declared guilty on his own admission” (Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Sanhedrin 13:1). This means that even if all witnesses testify against a defendant and everyone involved, including the defendant themselves, asserts guilt, the court may still acquit the defendant."
This decree emphasizes the importance of protecting the innocent and preventing wrongful convictions
No, I am not equating Gender Dysphoria as something to be guilty about, I am going over the decision making process.
So if a child believes they are in the wrong body and everyone around them agrees and reinforces it, it is wise to leave open the door for an acquittal from this fate (why, because only one side of the argument has been heard).
Securing the transgender "business" with a minor does not give the minor enough time to look into many of the reasons they feel they do not fit in this world or their body and it preys on the minors inability to comprehend nuances and complex factors that contribute to their current and future wellbeing.
The post and its chat with AI went down a path where even AI with its Bias toward woke ideology (that in itself is another topic) explored (some of) the complexities that go along with Gender Dysphoria. The chat also explored the motives of those caring for, teaching and influencing the Child and how they can impact a irreversible decision that might be applied to a child.
There is definitely an element of some people in the western civilized world that will be cruel towards those that are gay. in the Islamist world it unimaginably cruel with a throw "them" off the roof mentality.
Back to the Civilized world: Though not excused, the cruelty or push back from the general community is exacerbated with pride like movements that parade their sexual preference in front of other people's children and when inappropriate (age wise and content wise) books find their way into woke primary school libraries. There are others that will be resentful that the values they want their children to grow up with are being undermined by what is being taught in school, paraded in the media and on the streets and normalized (made to look "typical, average") ; even thrown in their faces at the Olympic games.
It is one thing to be accepting of children that are different and to that extent there should be equal or weighted emphasis on making classmates and the community aware of the challenges faced by:
Racial and Ethnic Minorities
Students with Learning Disabilities
Neurodivergent Students (Autism, ADHD, etc.)
Religious Minority Students
Students with Mental Health Conditions
Immigrant and Refugee Students
Students from Low-Income Families
English Language Learners (ELLs)
Students with Physical Disabilities
Students from Foster Care
For the Gender Minority Students (Gender Fluid, Non-Binary, Transgender) they too should be accepted and not bullied or isolated. Also important is that they should not be typecast, molded and chemically or surgically modified in a way that locks them into remaining into being defined by being a member of a minority group; especially when it could be a passing phase that, subject to counselling, they can get through without irreversible chemical ,surgical or even behavioral modelling that is currently directed toward them and their parents/guardians.
Accessing Grok to answer your question #7 (a tough one) leads me to believe that these open AI platforms have some serious built-in biases. Could Elon's purported "woke mind virus" (as it relates to his experience with his son's gender dysphoria)? I'll let you be the judge by posting Grok's response in a reply below.
Answer to Question #7 of the 12 posed by The nobody he knows everybody:
Answer
The question you've posed delves into complex and long-term mental health outcomes for transgender individuals who transition in childhood, particularly through the lens of social and familial dynamics over an extended lifespan. Here's a structured exploration based on the available information:
Short-term Benefits:
Immediate Mental Health Improvements: Studies, like the one found in the search results, indicate that transgender and nonbinary youths who receive gender-affirming care show reduced odds of depression and suicidality over a 12-month period. This suggests that in the short term, gender-affirming treatments can lead to significant psychological benefits.
Long-term Considerations:
Lack of Longitudinal Data: Most of the research to date has focused on short to medium-term outcomes. Comprehensive, long-term studies spanning decades are less common, making it difficult to predict with certainty the lifelong mental health trajectory for transgender individuals who transitioned in childhood.
Social and Familial Dynamics:
Alienation: As you've mentioned, over time, there could be a sense of alienation from peers who follow traditional life paths, which might impact mental health. This includes not sharing common experiences like biological parenthood or engaging in gender-specific activities traditionally.
Peer Relationships: The feeling of difference or isolation could potentially lead to increased mental health issues if the societal environment does not evolve to be more inclusive or supportive of diverse gender identities.
Regret and Satisfaction:
Detransition and Regret: There's a debate over the prevalence of regret among transgender individuals post-transition. Some sources, like the American College of Pediatricians mentioned in X posts, suggest that regret might occur, though this is controversial and not universally supported by scientific consensus.
Long-term Satisfaction: Conversely, other reports and studies highlight that a significant number of transgender individuals report satisfaction with their transition over time, feeling that their mental health has improved due to living as their affirmed gender.
Broader Societal Changes:
The evolution of societal attitudes towards transgender issues, legal recognitions, and workplace inclusivity could mitigate some of the potential negative long-term outcomes by fostering environments where transgender individuals are more integrated and accepted.
Speculative Long-term Outcomes:
Potential for Increased Anxiety: Without societal support or if facing ongoing discrimination, individuals might indeed experience higher levels of anxiety or depression due to the incongruence with societal norms or familial expectations.
Suicidal Ideation and Suicide Rates: While short-term studies show reductions in suicidal ideation, long-term outcomes could potentially differ if the individual faces persistent challenges in acceptance, relationship building, or if they experience regret or dissatisfaction with their transition.
Quality of Life: The overall quality of life could be influenced by how well a person can navigate or reshape their community and personal life to accommodate their identity, alongside factors like health care access, legal protections, and personal resilience.
Conclusion:
Given the current data, it's plausible that over a lifetime, the outcomes could vary significantly based on numerous factors including societal acceptance, personal support systems, and individual psychological resilience. While there might be short-term benefits from transitioning, the long-term implications are not fully understood due to the lack of long-term studies. This underscores the need for ongoing, long-term research to better understand these outcomes, and for society to continue evolving in its understanding and support of transgender individuals to potentially mitigate negative long-term effects.
For any definitive answer on long-term outcomes, we would need studies that follow cohorts over many decades, which are currently not available. However, it's crucial to approach this topic with an awareness of both the potential for positive outcomes through affirmation and the challenges that might arise from societal and personal dynamics over time.
The platforms tend to draw in from what they themselves can search.
And there is definitely Bias that comes through their answers.
A common and dangerous statement / path that the AI puppet is
"Well it looks good in the short term and we don't know what will happen in the long run ; so lets continue to do it regardless of safety signals and monitor the situation."
The logic is crazy, AI (and regulatory Authorities) should be providing informed consent where it should lead with the devastating possible outcomes that have not been shown to be without a basis and therefore should be ASSUMED to have a likelihood to take place in the absence of long term studies and in upholding the principle of First do no harm
It’s all based on lies. There is no real gender dysphoria. This is a perverted manipulation of young people’s inherent insecurities during adolescence. There is bias here from the start in the answers and in the questions themselves. The use of contrived terms like “gender assigned at birth“ indicate that the person using them has already agreed to the premise of gender. What gender? There is sex, male and female. Gender is a modern word not very precise in its meaning and that’s exactly why this movement has latched onto it. Sex is a fact established by one’s biology unless we are talking about very rare anomalies (aka birth defects). There has been a whole new vocabulary developed to try label and describe what is basically mental fiction. In other words the whole so called problem of gender dysphoria is really all made up and symptomatic of an ailing society that is really suffering emotional and mental illness. It’s just so much fiction; they contort language to define what they think they mean and then mutilate the body to match the figment of their imagination. They are at war with themselves as God’s creation and so try to recreate who they are becoming gods unto themselves. It is perverted, suicidal and homicidal in nature. It is the ultimate expression of hatred toward God. It is simply sinful and therefore at its core a spiritual problem that has only one possible solution reconciliation with God by accepting his Son, Jesus Christ, as lord and savior.
A well constructed response pointing out the manipulation and even fabrication of language to support a narrative. I suspect ChatGPT is programmed with some degree of woke Narrative. ChatGPT may be direct programming like YouTube in manipulating what "gets through the gate" or seen with woke crafted algorithms. ChatGPT may be constricted intentionally or incidentally to woke based information on which to base its answers.
Christians may have it right, Jews may have it Right, and other God Fearing/Respecting Religions and Sects may have it right but the main form of your thoughts is : in all but very rare disorders "Sex is a fact established by one’s (God Given) biology ".
Unfortunately, the hate against Transgender people has already reached such a momentum that the affected can only be considered scapegoats for obvious reasons. As a person dealing with the issue, I have been writing about it for a long time. Without AI - but at the core emphasizing - and demanding that the main attention been given to mental health care. Gender Dysphoria - and that is not addressed - is most prevalent in people with Asperger’s. It is a form of autism and therefor requires affirming mental health care. The problems arise when a society cannot accept individuals “as is”, leading to the impression that there is “something wrong” with me. The entire issue will disappear when society does not exclude individuals that try to “fix” something that can best be treated with acceptance and love. The sad and quite sick part about this topic is the hate against autistic people for lack of understanding that autism is a disorder that has its roots in vaccinations and certain environ-mental settings. Think of aluminum poisoning. That the dark and sinister forces use the issue to divide the population is a fact. The Olympic games closing ceremony showed that with undeniable clarity. One can only wonder why there are so many religious people among the haters. The biblical advise exists however, that one should not so much care about the splinter in another one’s eye as one should focus on the log in one’s own eye. But if that would be the case, this would not be a “profoundly sick society”.
I suggest most of the Doctors and experts wanting to put an end to the industry that makes a lot of money with irreversible chemical and surgical "offerings" on minors come from a position of Love and Respect for Humanity. This group of people are likely to provide more time, love, care and long term counselling than those that approach a child's Gender Dysphoria with a heavy bias, if not one tracked mind, of a Gender Transformation as the most likely solution.
I think you touched on some really important issues including the link with Neurodivergent people and Gender Dysphoria. And then the link between big Pharma and the childhood 70+ vaccines schedule with not one of the vaccines being blind tested individually nor any combination profile safety testing. Vaccine adjuvants including Aluminum based ones are a real concern though there are also many other sinister elements in the way the vaccine industry operates and the contents they are using in the vaccines.
When a child is confused about their identity (which can include their Gender) they are very vulnerable and impressionable. Add to that the correlation of Gender Dysphoria and Neurodivergence and it becomes quite despicable for the industry that makes a lot of money with irreversible chemical and surgical "offerings" on minors to be pushing for quick paths (while they are minors) to this irreversible option.
When looking for religious guidance, I would look at the approach of the Jewish Scholars; in revising their texts and interpretations of what is morally right (over thousands of years) they look at a problem from as many angles as possible.
If you look up the "Unanimous Guilty Acquittal Rule"
"In Jewish law, a court’s decision is guided by the principle that “no one is to be declared guilty on his own admission” (Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Sanhedrin 13:1). This means that even if all witnesses testify against a defendant and everyone involved, including the defendant themselves, asserts guilt, the court may still acquit the defendant."
This decree emphasizes the importance of protecting the innocent and preventing wrongful convictions
No, I am not equating Gender Dysphoria as something to be guilty about, I am going over the decision making process.
So if a child believes they are in the wrong body and everyone around them agrees and reinforces it, it is wise to leave open the door for an acquittal from this fate (why, because only one side of the argument has been heard).
Securing the transgender "business" with a minor does not give the minor enough time to look into many of the reasons they feel they do not fit in this world or their body and it preys on the minors inability to comprehend nuances and complex factors that contribute to their current and future wellbeing.
The post and its chat with AI went down a path where even AI with its Bias toward woke ideology (that in itself is another topic) explored (some of) the complexities that go along with Gender Dysphoria. The chat also explored the motives of those caring for, teaching and influencing the Child and how they can impact a irreversible decision that might be applied to a child.
There is definitely an element of some people in the western civilized world that will be cruel towards those that are gay. in the Islamist world it unimaginably cruel with a throw "them" off the roof mentality.
Back to the Civilized world: Though not excused, the cruelty or push back from the general community is exacerbated with pride like movements that parade their sexual preference in front of other people's children and when inappropriate (age wise and content wise) books find their way into woke primary school libraries. There are others that will be resentful that the values they want their children to grow up with are being undermined by what is being taught in school, paraded in the media and on the streets and normalized (made to look "typical, average") ; even thrown in their faces at the Olympic games.
It is one thing to be accepting of children that are different and to that extent there should be equal or weighted emphasis on making classmates and the community aware of the challenges faced by:
Racial and Ethnic Minorities
Students with Learning Disabilities
Neurodivergent Students (Autism, ADHD, etc.)
Religious Minority Students
Students with Mental Health Conditions
Immigrant and Refugee Students
Students from Low-Income Families
English Language Learners (ELLs)
Students with Physical Disabilities
Students from Foster Care
For the Gender Minority Students (Gender Fluid, Non-Binary, Transgender) they too should be accepted and not bullied or isolated. Also important is that they should not be typecast, molded and chemically or surgically modified in a way that locks them into remaining into being defined by being a member of a minority group; especially when it could be a passing phase that, subject to counselling, they can get through without irreversible chemical ,surgical or even behavioral modelling that is currently directed toward them and their parents/guardians.
Whew. I don't know. Chat GBT really let me down when I first played around with it. (https://rreggievanderveen.substack.com/p/openai-drops-a-turd)
Accessing Grok to answer your question #7 (a tough one) leads me to believe that these open AI platforms have some serious built-in biases. Could Elon's purported "woke mind virus" (as it relates to his experience with his son's gender dysphoria)? I'll let you be the judge by posting Grok's response in a reply below.
Answer to Question #7 of the 12 posed by The nobody he knows everybody:
Answer
The question you've posed delves into complex and long-term mental health outcomes for transgender individuals who transition in childhood, particularly through the lens of social and familial dynamics over an extended lifespan. Here's a structured exploration based on the available information:
Short-term Benefits:
Immediate Mental Health Improvements: Studies, like the one found in the search results, indicate that transgender and nonbinary youths who receive gender-affirming care show reduced odds of depression and suicidality over a 12-month period. This suggests that in the short term, gender-affirming treatments can lead to significant psychological benefits.
Long-term Considerations:
Lack of Longitudinal Data: Most of the research to date has focused on short to medium-term outcomes. Comprehensive, long-term studies spanning decades are less common, making it difficult to predict with certainty the lifelong mental health trajectory for transgender individuals who transitioned in childhood.
Social and Familial Dynamics:
Alienation: As you've mentioned, over time, there could be a sense of alienation from peers who follow traditional life paths, which might impact mental health. This includes not sharing common experiences like biological parenthood or engaging in gender-specific activities traditionally.
Peer Relationships: The feeling of difference or isolation could potentially lead to increased mental health issues if the societal environment does not evolve to be more inclusive or supportive of diverse gender identities.
Regret and Satisfaction:
Detransition and Regret: There's a debate over the prevalence of regret among transgender individuals post-transition. Some sources, like the American College of Pediatricians mentioned in X posts, suggest that regret might occur, though this is controversial and not universally supported by scientific consensus.
Long-term Satisfaction: Conversely, other reports and studies highlight that a significant number of transgender individuals report satisfaction with their transition over time, feeling that their mental health has improved due to living as their affirmed gender.
Broader Societal Changes:
The evolution of societal attitudes towards transgender issues, legal recognitions, and workplace inclusivity could mitigate some of the potential negative long-term outcomes by fostering environments where transgender individuals are more integrated and accepted.
Speculative Long-term Outcomes:
Potential for Increased Anxiety: Without societal support or if facing ongoing discrimination, individuals might indeed experience higher levels of anxiety or depression due to the incongruence with societal norms or familial expectations.
Suicidal Ideation and Suicide Rates: While short-term studies show reductions in suicidal ideation, long-term outcomes could potentially differ if the individual faces persistent challenges in acceptance, relationship building, or if they experience regret or dissatisfaction with their transition.
Quality of Life: The overall quality of life could be influenced by how well a person can navigate or reshape their community and personal life to accommodate their identity, alongside factors like health care access, legal protections, and personal resilience.
Conclusion:
Given the current data, it's plausible that over a lifetime, the outcomes could vary significantly based on numerous factors including societal acceptance, personal support systems, and individual psychological resilience. While there might be short-term benefits from transitioning, the long-term implications are not fully understood due to the lack of long-term studies. This underscores the need for ongoing, long-term research to better understand these outcomes, and for society to continue evolving in its understanding and support of transgender individuals to potentially mitigate negative long-term effects.
For any definitive answer on long-term outcomes, we would need studies that follow cohorts over many decades, which are currently not available. However, it's crucial to approach this topic with an awareness of both the potential for positive outcomes through affirmation and the challenges that might arise from societal and personal dynamics over time.
The platforms tend to draw in from what they themselves can search.
And there is definitely Bias that comes through their answers.
A common and dangerous statement / path that the AI puppet is
"Well it looks good in the short term and we don't know what will happen in the long run ; so lets continue to do it regardless of safety signals and monitor the situation."
The logic is crazy, AI (and regulatory Authorities) should be providing informed consent where it should lead with the devastating possible outcomes that have not been shown to be without a basis and therefore should be ASSUMED to have a likelihood to take place in the absence of long term studies and in upholding the principle of First do no harm